Page 1 of 1

engine comparison opinions

Posted: Mon Apr 14, 2014 8:02 pm
by johnp
What are anyones opinions experiences with Tiny Power W and M engine. 6a didn't pan out. I have an 18.5' boat with room for a 15" dia propellar, and a 30 sqft WT boiler.

Re: engine comparison opinions

Posted: Mon Apr 14, 2014 10:09 pm
by DetroiTug
The M is a good engine and the W probably is too. Tiny Power sells good quality castings with ample material for machining. I've seen their fully machined and assembled engines and they were nicely done. The W is a pretty small engine, but may be about right for an 18 foot launch. After running the Twin M, I would opt for the W twin for your application. And it's a column engine, which I think looks a little better.

-Ron

Re: engine comparison opinions

Posted: Tue Apr 15, 2014 3:42 am
by artemis
johnp wrote:What are anyones opinions experiences with Tiny Power W and M engine. 6a didn't pan out. I have an 18.5' boat with room for a 15" dia propellar, and a 30 sqft WT boiler.
Dick Small built the Chester D, a 20' rose hull, and fitted her with a "W" engine and she's still running around, operating on the second "W". More about the boat on the Northwest Steam Society website, under "boats &c" or: http://www.northweststeamsociety.org/Pa ... SSBche.htm

Re: engine comparison opinions

Posted: Fri Apr 18, 2014 5:26 am
by Wayleon
I have the Chester D now. To date I haven't gotten much experience with her, but spring is upon us. Richard Small ran her at 80 psi, and given the age of the boiler I will keep the 100 psi safety valve. With higher pressure and a 30 sq ft boiler the W should be able to deal with an 18 ft boat of reasonable displacement.
-Wayne