Page 2 of 2

Re: Newbie now has hull for "just an engine"

Posted: Fri Dec 30, 2016 2:01 pm
by PeteThePen1
Hi Nick

Another thought for you. If you look at the SBA website (I imagine that you will have joined up by now!), and go to the Steamboat Register and do an Advanced search with the ST 5A as the search parameter. As always you may need to play about with the fine detail of the parameter, but it will eventually give you a listing of all the boats powered by that engine. You can then get a feel for what folk have done before not to mention a feel for the style of boilers used.

Of course the alternative is to put in the hull size and see what comes back.

Hope it helps

Regards

Pete

Re: Newbie now has hull for "just an engine"

Posted: Fri Dec 30, 2016 2:37 pm
by RGSP
PeteThePen1 wrote:Hi Nick

Another thought for you. If you look at the SBA website (I imagine that you will have joined up by now!), and go to the Steamboat Register and do an Advanced search with the ST 5A as the search parameter. As always you may need to play about with the fine detail of the parameter, but it will eventually give you a listing of all the boats powered by that engine. You can then get a feel for what folk have done before not to mention a feel for the style of boilers used.

Of course the alternative is to put in the hull size and see what comes back.

Hope it helps

Regards

Pete
That's jolly good advice. Senta certainly performs nicely on Windermere with a 5A in a Flying Dutchman (racing sailing dinghy) hull, burning wood in a VFT boiler.

The other way to look at a 5A is the amount of power available is about the same as two normal people rowing moderately hard (or maybe one olympic oarsman), and you might be able to guess the perfomance adequately from that.

Re: Newbie now has hull for "just an engine"

Posted: Sun Jan 01, 2017 2:04 pm
by Nick C
Hi All

Happy New Year. Thank you for your further input.

Bart

I will probably put it together with what I have, but keep on the look out for a bigger pitch prop.

Fredrosse

The Javelin is a nice looking hull, I assume you have the iron keel version. Similar weight and dimensions to Drascombe Dabber. Much encouraged that I have good chance of making a successful boat, probably with a different prop. Thanks

Scott

Thanks for the book recommendation. I have Vol 3 on order from a UK bookshop that had it in stock. How many volumes were there? Have I got the right volume?

Pete

I have joined SBA and looking at other boats with similar hulls and ST 5a. Especially interested in the prop sizes used. One problem with this approach is you get no feel for the actual performance. Frances Ann looks good, where do you steam her?

RGSP

So I need to find a friend or an Olympic rower to do a trial! It’s encouraging that others have success with the ST 5a. The Flying Dutchman is a planing hull, while the Drascombe is a displacement hull. So, no chance of hoping on top of the wave to gain higher speeds with the Dabber.

Nick

Re: Newbie now has hull for "just an engine" now little prog

Posted: Mon Feb 13, 2017 9:59 am
by Nick C
Hi All

Not made much progress with the steamboat. It has been as low as -6 oC in the workshop! The situation at present is that I have hull and engine. On the look out for a prop with larger pitch than the one I have.

The last big item is a boiler, which has got me doing layouts. I realised that I have never fully considered where everything goes.

The position of the engine is fixed within limits at the end of the stern tube. But I need to stoke the boiler from a coal store, control the engine (reverse lever actually on Stuart 5a) with the regulator, have sight of water level and control water feed. Also access items such as blower and whistle. Plus steer the boat by tiller or wheel. Preferably without leaving my seat.

Everything has to be positioned so the hull remains level and stable.

What have I left out?

Nick

Re: Newbie now has hull for "just an engine"

Posted: Mon Feb 13, 2017 1:23 pm
by Mike Cole
Will you be fitting a hot well ?

Re: Newbie now has hull for "just an engine"

Posted: Tue Feb 14, 2017 9:04 am
by Nick C
Hi Mike

Hot Well !! What that ???
Not in the index of the SBA Steamboating Guide.

Probably not a means of having an onboard hot tub.

Is it for use with a condenser? My thinking at present is top keep things simple and not condense of this time. It might be a good idea to leave appropriate space if I decide to retro fit a condenser.

Please tell me more.

Nick

Re: Newbie now has hull for "just an engine"

Posted: Tue Feb 14, 2017 3:54 pm
by Mike Cole
yes a hot well is for the returning hot water from a condenser. Mine is too small I need to make a better one, but I think I will do without the airpump , which is the one that draw the water/air mix from the condenser. By puffing ie exhust steam up the funnel then you can get a good blast on the fire.